Mike Orenduff… on Falling In and Out of Like With Mystery Fiction

The Mystery We Write Blog Tour advances to Day Five. Our guest blogger today is Mike Orenduff, who grew up in a house so close to the Rio Grande that he could Frisbee a tortilla into Mexico. He came by his love of pueblo pottery during weekends, buying small pots from the pueblos his family visited and – in one case – acquiring one when his sister traded chocolate chip cookies for it. His love of pottery expanded to a general interest in archaeology which he studied as an undergraduate. Visit his website at www.orenduff.org

While in graduate school at the University of New Mexico, Mike worked during the summer as a volunteer teacher at one of the nearby pueblos. He went on to serve as President of New Mexico State University and as a visiting faculty member at West Point and President of Bermuda College. After retiring from higher education, he rekindled his love of the Southwest by writing his award-winning Pot Thief murder mysteries which combine archaeology and philosophy with humor and mystery.  Among his many awards are the New Mexico Book of the Year, the “Lefty” national award for best humorous mystery and two “Eppies” for the best eBook mysteries.

His first book, The Pot Thief Who Studied Pythagoras, was described by The Baltimore Sun as, “funny at a very high intellectual level and deliciously delightful,” and his latest, The Pot Thief Who Studied Escoffier, was called “the perfect fusion of murder, mayhem and margaritas” by The El Paso Times.


I’ve been reading a collection of Sherlock Holmes stories. I hadn’t read Doyle since high school and wondered if I would still like his stories. I do, but for an entirely different reason. I read every known Holmes story when I was a teenager because I loved the puzzles. I didn’t much like the movies because I thought they concentrated too much on Holmes’ personality, but I loved the books. Re-reading them half a century later (I can’t believe I got so old so fast), my opinion has completely reversed. The puzzles are not so engaging, perhaps because I now invent them myself and realize it is no great achievement to do so. But the personalities are of interest. I don’t much like Holmes, but Watson makes up for that. What entertains us changes as we change. Our taste improves. Or at least we hope it does; maybe it just changes. I used to like westerns. Now I don’t. I used to like Nero Wolfe. Now I don’t. I didn’t like Raymond Chandler (go figure). Now I do.

To quote Ron Benrey, “the list of things we enjoy about mysteries is endless: the puzzle, the setting, the people, the odd facts presented, the triumph of ‘good’ at the end, details about food and hobbies, etc.” Of course, not every book will contain all those elements, and not every reader likes the same ones, which is why there is room for so many different mystery writers.

I like the Pippa Hunnechurch Mysteries by Ron and Janet Benrey because of the humor and the food. I knew I was going to like Bauble and Squeak just from the title. If you get the pun, you’ll love the book.

I like the Bernie Rhodenbarr series because of the setting – Bernie’s bookshop and Carolyn’s dog grooming business are on the exact block where I own a pied-a-terre in Manhattan. Except they aren’t of course, because they are fictional.

I like Marilyn Meredith’s Rocky Bluff PD series because it is like a visit to a small town with interesting people.

I like the Archy McNally series because of the breezy style of Archie, sort of the modern version of Nick in the “Thin Man” movies.

I like Beth Anderson’s books because of the swashbuckling adventures.

There are many other series I like for many other reasons.

Happily, many readers enjoy my books. I do twenty to fifty signings a year and receive hundreds of emails from readers. (I actually received a hand-written fan letter this year; how often does that happen these days?) Here is what they say they like about my books. I don’t keep an actual tally, but I think the order would be something like this: the protagonist, the humor, the setting, the quirkiness and the food. Notice that no one mentions the murders. The El Paso Times has reviewed all my books and said in their review of the latest one, The Pot Thief Who Studied Escoffier, “as usual, the murder is an aside.”

So I’ll leave you with this observation to ponder. I think the murder is an aside in all mystery novels. And the romance is an aside in romance novels. The futurist science is an aside in science fiction. Books are about their characters, and they work when the characters and the writing are both engaging.


Mike’s mystery novels — The Pot Thief Who Studied Pythagoras, The Pot Thief Who Studied Ptolemy, The Pot Thief Who Studied Einstein, and The Pot Thief Who Studied Escoffier are published by Oak Tress Press and are available as paperbacks in many Barnes & Nobles, Hastings, and Independent bookstores and as ebooks for Kindle and Nook readers.

Here’s the link to Mike’s latest novel: http://tiny.cc/hkps0

20 Comments

Jinx Schwartz … on the Importance of Entertaining Readers

My guest blogger on Day Four of the Mystery We Write Blog Tour has a background that’s almost as colorful as the mystery novels she writes. Jinx Schwartz was raised in the jungles of Haiti and Thailand, with returns to Texas in-between, as Jinx followed her father’s steel-toed footsteps into the construction and engineering industry in hopes of building dams. Finding all the good rivers taken, she traveled the world defacing other landscapes with mega-projects in Alaska, Japan, New Zealand, Puerto Rico and Mexico.

Like the protagonist in her mystery series, Hetta Coffey, Jinx was a woman with a yacht—and she wasn’t afraid to use it — when she met her husband, Mad Dog Schwartz. They opted to become cash-poor cruisers rather than continue chasing the rat. And so, they sailed under the Golden Gate Bridge, turned left, and headed for Mexico. They now divide their time between Arizona and Mexico’s Sea of Cortez.


Why do I think readers are entertained by mystery novels?

There are so many genres of the mystery novel these days that I think important factors drawing readers are genre, setting, and the protagonist’s profession. That said, a good book is a good draw, no matter what. Mysteries add, well, mystery to our daily lives and tax our abilities to be as smart (or dumb) as the protagonist. How many times have we thought, “Oh, no! She’s not really going to walk down that dark alley, is she?” or “Heh, heh, that bad guy doesn’t know who he’s tangled with.”

I read fiction for entertainment, and like a good laugh with my mystery, and so I write humorous mysteries. Is my Hetta Coffey mystery series going win a Pulitzer Prize? Nope, but my readers love Hetta, a globe-trotting civil engineer with attitude who is working on coming of age, a little late. Oh, and by the way, she can be very smart…and very dumb. The fact that she is usually heavily armed helps with the dumb part.

Just Add Water, first in the series (and winner of an EPPIE for Best Mystery) introduces us to Hetta, and Hetta to the world of boating. Just Add Salt finds Hetta taking her boat to Mexico despite being spectacularly unqualified to do so; in Just Add Trouble she ends up in Mexico’s hauntingly beautiful Sea of Cortez; and the latest release, Just Deserts land her smack dab on the tumultuous Arizona/Mexico border.

As you can see, that Hetta gets around.

Hetta fans tell me they like the series for various reasons, but overall they just want to see what Hetta will get into, and out of, next. She knows few boundaries and is, on the surface, fearless to the point of foolish. Or is she? We all get ourselves into messes; it’s just that hers are more flamboyant.

I believe the mystery novel as entertainment is so popular because the reader escapes to other worlds, and may even be inspired to step out of their own. Not a mystery, but when I read James Michener’s The Source years ago, I hopped a jet for Israel, a place I vaguely knew existed before reading the book. Next thing I knew, I was sifting dirt at the Wailing Wall excavation. I’ve had people tell me the reason they bought a boat and sailed to Mexico was because of my one of my books. Of course, that alone might question the reader’s IQ, since a voyage into Mexican waters in one of my books is fraught with danger.

Another of my books that readers find entertaining is Land of Mountains, a mysterious adventure set in Haiti in the 1950’s. Why? Perhaps because it transports us to a time and place where little girls were free to ride horses through jungles and hang out with zombies. This book is a finalist for EPIC’s 2012 Best YA, but is suitable for all ages.


The Hetta Coffey Series is available in ebook formats, audio and print. You can read the first chapter of each book on Jinx’s website at jinxschwartz.com

The following short link will take you to the series’ Amazon page: http://amzn.to/o0gXOy

13 Comments

Earl Staggs … on Why Readers Love a Good Mystery Story

We’ve reached Day 3 of the 2011 Mystery We Write Blog Tour. Our guest blogger today is Earl Staggs, winner of the Derringer Award — a polished writer who loves short mystery fiction. Earl’s short stories have been published in many different magazines and anthologies. He served as Managing Editor of Futures Mystery Magazine and as President of the Short Mystery Fiction Society. But Earl is also a mystery novelist: His novel Memory of a Murder earned thirteen five-star reviews online at Amazon and B&N.

Earl’s column “Write Tight” appears in the online magazine Apollo’s Lyre. He is also a contributing blog member of Murderous Musings and Make Mine Mystery. He hosts workshops for the Muse Online Writers Conference and the Catholic Writers Conference Online, and is a frequent speaker at conferences and writers groups.

Visit Earl’s website at earlwstaggs.wordpress.com (Note the “w” in the address; it’s important!)


Why are readers entertained by mystery novels?

Your question is a great one for mystery writers as well as readers, Ron, and one I’ve given a lot of thought to. I think there are three main reasons:

First of all, I think Mystery readers are like me and enjoy solving a puzzle. Reading a mystery story gives us an opportunity to follow the clues and figure out whodunit. If the novel is written well enough, we can immerse ourselves in it and feel as if we’re part of the investigation, working side-by-side with the fictional sleuth. The writer has to be careful, of course. The clues have to be there for us as well as the sleuth, but not so obvious that we’ll figure it out too soon. If that happens, we may lose interest in reading that book and any others by that writer. That’s the challenge for the Mystery writer, and we’re very happy when we find a writer who can hold our interest all the way to The End.

The second big reason, I think, is that mystery readers enjoy seeing the bad guys get caught and punished. We don’t always see that happen in real life. When we see criminals slip through cracks in the legal system and evade justice with loopholes and clever lawyers, it’s reassuring to pick up a good Mystery novel and know that’s not going to happen.

Third, mystery readers like to spend time with fictional characters we’d like to have as friends in real life and have on our side if we get in trouble. There’s not much pleasure reading chapter after chapter about characters we can’t relate to or wouldn’t want to live next door to.

When I created Adam Kingston, the protagonist in my novel Memory of a Murder, I wanted him to be the kind of man readers would like and would invite home to dinner. Adam Kingston has a special gift to help him solve crimes, but when he’s not using his gift, he leads a normal life. Like the rest of us, he has a past which influences how he lives each day, he has close friends he knows will be there for him if he needs them, and he makes mistakes and judgment errors just as we do. Once I had a handle on Adam, the challenge was to put him in a story that would challenge readers right along with him. While Adam tries to uncover the secrets behind a sixteen-year-old murder, he has to deal with someone who is killing people to keep those secrets from being revealed. I did my best to plant clues leading him and readers to the killer, but keep readers guessing. So far, no one has been able to figure it out until Adam does in the final chapters.


Memory of a Murder

You’re invited to get to know Adam by reading Chapter One of Memory of a Murder on my website at: earlwstaggs.wordpress.com
You can also read “The Day I Almost Became a Great Writer,” which some say is the funniest story I’ve ever written. There’s another one there called “White Hats and Happy Trails,” about the day I spent with a boyhood idol, Roy Rogers.

While you’re there, please visit with my special guest for the day, a mystery writer I’m sure you’ll enjoy.

And please don’t forget to sign up for the drawing on December 9. The first name drawn from those who leave a comment will receive a print copy of Memory of a Murder. The second name drawn will have a choice of an ebook or print copy of Short Stories of Earl Staggs, a collection of sixteen of my best short stories.

10 Comments

Anne K. Albert… on Why Readers Love the Mystery Fiction Genre

It’s Day 2 of the second 2011 Mystery We Write Blog Tour and I’m delighted to welcome Anne K. Albert. Anne’s award winning stories chill the spine, warm the heart and soothe the soul… all with a delightful touch of humor. A member of Romance Writers of America, Mystery Writers of America, Sisters in Crime, and married to her high school sweetheart for more than a quarter of a century, it’s a given she’d write mystery and romantic suspense. When not writing she loves to travel, visit friends and family, and of course, read using ‘Threegio’ her cherished and much beloved Kindle 3G!


I’m excited to talk writing — specifically why readers read the mystery fiction genre.

I’d like to begin by stating most readers never stop to consider why they read mysteries. Nor should they. Still, the mystery reader, like the romance, horror, or fantasy genre reader, has certain expectations of mystery authors. Writers are obliged to deliver the goods. Failure to do so could result in a decline in readership and sales, and no author wants that.

What are these expectations? The good news is they’re not as mysterious as one would think!

Readers read mysteries, especially cozies, to be entertained. They want to forget about the real world and spend a few hours immersed in a fast-paced, well written story with a beginning, middle and end that makes complete sense and appeals to their moral well-being. They want to read about murder, yet be spared the graphic detail. They want the suspense without the terror. And if the story includes a little romance and humor, all the better!

Readers crave a story with memorable characters. They want to cheer for the underdog, often an amateur sleuth, as she solves the mystery. They also want to meet a cast of characters who walk off the page and step into their living room.

While readers identify with these characters, they also scrutinize them. This is one aspect that differs from other genres where the reader experiences the story through the eyes of the protagonist. In most genres, readers tend to accept the character’s truth as their own. Mystery readers, however, examine each character with care…and often glee! Is this individual telling the truth? Does her alibi hold up? What does she have to gain by lying? Readers look past the obvious and like any seasoned detective search for the truth.

This brings us to the puzzle. Mysteries are who dunnits. The author challenges the reader to solve the mystery. The reader is actively engaged, searching for clues and red herrings at the same time as the protagonist. This allows the reader to be simultaneously inside and outside of the story as she struggles to outsmart not only the villain and detective, but the author as well.

Many mysteries deal with death. Death in the real world is an at-arms-length experience we don’t understand or want. It defies reason and seems irrational. But in a mystery story, death is rational. What happens can and will eventually be explained. The world inside a mystery novel makes complete sense. The villain is caught. Justice is served. Good triumphs over evil. The story characters and the reader gets closure. Mystery novels are a win/win situation, and that’s why readers read them and writers write them!


Frank, Incense and Muriel

… is the first book of Anne’s Muriel Reeves Mysteries. It’s the week before Christmas when the stress of the holidays is enough to frazzle anyone’s nerves. Tensions increase when a friend begs Muriel to team up with her sexy high school nemesis, now an even sexier private investigator to find a missing woman. Forced to deal with an embezzler, kidnapper, and femme fatale is bad enough, but add Muriel’s zany yet loveable family to the mix and their desire to win the coveted D-DAY (Death Defying Act of the Year) Award, and the situation can only get worse.

What are readers saying?

“Anne K. Albert’s… wit shines through this lightly suspenseful novel and her characters ring sweet and true. Can’t wait to read more about Muriel, Frank and the rest of the gang.” — Amazon reviewer

“This author knows how to entertain her readers and keeps them wanting to turn the page to see what happens next. If you’re looking for a story with a little bit of humor, a whole lot of suspense and plenty of insanity, then you’ve found the perfect story. I’m highly recommending this story to other readers and I’m definitely adding this book to my library. You won’t be disappointed buying this book or others penned by this author. Great job, Ms. Albert! Keep the stories coming!” — Diana Coyle, Night Owl Reviews

Frank, Incense and Muriel received the prestigious 2011 Holt Medallion Award of Merit. If you’d like to read a sample, visit: http://amzn.to/pg67sx. Or visit Anne’s website www.AnneKAlbert.com.

Frank, Incense and Muriel is available at Amazon — http://www.amazon.com/Frank-Incense-and-Muriel-ebook/dp/B004CLYDRO — and many other retailers, both in paper and eBook versions.

21 Comments

Beth Anderson… on Why Mystery Novels Are Fun to Read (and Write)

Our first guest blogger is Beth Anderson — a multi-published, award winning author in several genres including romance and mainstream crime fiction. A full time author, she now lives in Washington state. She has appeared on Chicago’s WGN Morning Show, The ABC Evening News, as well as numerous other radio and cable television shows. She has guest lectured at Purdue University, Moraine Valley College, and many libraries and writers’ conferences. She loves music, particularly jazz. Her website and blog are at www.bethanderson-hotclue.com


Why are readers entertained by mystery novels (what are the different factors that entertain readers)?

Oh, I think people read mystery novels for all kinds of reasons. Some because they want to solve the mystery as they read along. Some just because they love a puzzle, whether they can solve it or not. Some because since mysteries are not generally touted as ‘literary fiction, they feel these are books that can be read at leisure and put aside for a while, then gone back to. Some love quilting or cooking or whatever niche/hobby mysteries because they like the hobby aspect of it. Some are going to work like crazy to keep track of clues and have the capacity to do so. And some dote on mysteries with various animals featured because they just flat out love those animals and will read anything with animals in it and they’re happy.
What aspects of the mystery novels you read do you enjoy most?

I like mysteries that are a little more hard-hitting; in other words, my own preference is for the more realistic mainstream mysteries. I like it when they read fast, without a lot of internalizing by everyone in the book, and I very much want them to be believable, which pretty much eliminates futuristic mysteries for me because I’m not much of a science fiction reader. I have to have realism, or enough to be believable.

For me to enjoy a mystery, I don’t have to solve the puzzle as I go along; I’m quite happy to let the author surprise me at the end and I’d never remember all the clues anyhow. When I’m doing pleasure reading, I don’t want to have to stretch my brain and patience enough to keep track of clues. I’ll always buy into a realistic cast who say what they feel like saying EXCEPT when they use really foul language—for instance, you can eliminate all F-bombs and all erotic language and just tell it like it is without trying to titillate me and I’ll be a happy camper. So if I had to put it in one word, that word would be “realism”. (Of course, though, that’s my personal realism I’m speaking about. Others who have lived a different life may see other things as realistic.

What makes YOUR novel(s) entertaining?

To me or the reader? ;-) I ask that because I have to have fun writing my mysteries or else I’ll get bored and start something else. I like to have secondary characters who are quirky or amusing, and I do this mainly with dialogue. Those are often my favorite characters. I also use their quirkiness to misdirect the reader, which can be fun for both me and them.

A lot depends on what type of mystery I’m writing. If it’s going to be a serious murder mystery with life-and-death situations, the only really funny characters will have to be secondary. In that type of book the leads will be pretty serious most of the time because they’re the ones who have the most to lose.

Funny characters to me are also a matter of pacing. I think there have to be highs and lows flowing all through the book. You have your high drama moments, then, lowering the stakes temporarily, something not quite so dramatic and shattering. I love to write in red herrings that people don’t really see as red herrings. This is why almost everyone tells me they never can figure out who my killer is until one of my leads tells them, and with some people, not even then. That alone gives me a lot of satisfaction because when that happens, I know my pacing and my own diabolical-ness (if that’s a word) was right on.

One final word on this: I think writing mysteries is the most fun in the whole world. I love it when I can write and laugh at the same time, and I often do. I love it when even before I start writing a book I hear conversations that will be in the book already in my head, and some of them are funny enough to me that I’ll laugh out loud. I have to admit this gets me a lot of stares. I try not to laugh too hard though, lest men with white suits and nets come after me.
So far they haven’t. Apparently I’ve even got them fooled. ;-)


Raven Talks Back

… is Beth Anderson’s latest mystery novel. The story takes place in beautiful Valdez, Alaska — home of twenty-three-inch snow in the wintertime, but in the summertime, gorgeous mountain scenery where the early morning fog rolls down the mountainside, bringing soft whispers of the past with it. And this year — murder.

Valdez Chief of Police Jack O’Banion’s take: Voices. Visions. A sadistic killer running around loose, a hysterical woman, two teenagers on the verge of home-grown terrorism, everybody including the Alaska State Troopers and out-of-town media driving him berserk twenty-four hours a day. And now Raven wants him to arrest someone, anyone, because she thinks her husband is about to be charged with murder and she just can’t face it.

Raven Morressey’s take: She knows nothing she’s saying to Jack makes any sense to him because it doesn’t to her, either. After all, it’s not every day a newly murdered, tattooed, headless and handless body is dug up in your back yard and then you start hearing voices of your dead ancestors and seeing things that never happened — at least yet. She just wants to keep her home together — at first. She’s not trying to butt in and solve the murders in Valdez. But she just can’t help it.

RAVEN TALKS BACK by Beth Anderson is published by Krill Press, ISBN 978-0-9821443-9-8

It’s available at Amazon — http://www.amazon.com/Raven-Talks-Back-Beth-Anderson/dp/0982144393 — and many other retailers, both in paper and eBook versions.

11 Comments

Get Ready for a Torrent of Mystery Writers

And a Friendly Contest That May Interest You

I recently offered a limited answer to the question, what kind of person writes mystery novels? I noted several common-denominator characteristics, including diverse backgrounds, interesting day jobs, a love of traveling, and zeal for mystery fiction (both as readers and writers).

I admit that when I was framing my response, I kept thinking of the fourteen other working mystery novelists who frequently participate periodic Mystery We Write Blog Tours. I snapped up the opportunity when Anne K. Albert, the tour organizer, invited me to join their august company. And I’m delighted that The Benrey Blog will be a stop on the “Holiday Tour” that begins on November 25 and continues through December 8.

We’ll have a different guest blogger each day — each a multi-published mystery writer and each an inveterate blogger who loves to communicate with mystery readers. A blog tour is a great way to meet new mystery writers and get introduced to their latest novels. It’s also lots of fun.

When I was asked to propose a nominal topic for their visits to The Benrey Blog, I primed the pump with several related question: Why are readers entertained by mystery novels? What aspects of the mystery novels you read do you enjoy most? What makes your mystery novels entertaining?

As I expected, most of the writers went off on fascinating tangents that will tell you lots more about them — as unusual authors of mystery fiction.

My 14 guest bloggers are:

As everyone knows, blogs are all about two-way communications. I hope you’ll make a flood of comments about the different posts. To encourage your participation, I’ll award paper or eBook copies of Dead as a Scone or The Final Crumpet to the folks who post the THREE BEST comments during the blog tour.

I’ll announce the winners on December 9, in a “Recap” post that marks the end of the tour.

Enjoy!

4 Comments

What Kind of People Write Mystery Novels?

The other day, a friend asked me, “What kind of person writes mystery novels?” He went on to qualify — and sharpen — his question: “I’ve seen you talking with Janet. Your eyes glow when you figure out a new way to kill someone.”

I abruptly understood. He had zeroed-in on one of the odder characteristics of mystery authors — and wondered if we’re all weird in that way. I agreed that some mystery novelists have unnatural interests in murder and mayhem. I’ve heard many a tableful of mystery writers at conferences like Bouchercon and Malice Domestic chat merrily at breakfast about undetectable poisons, horrific gunshot wounds, and perfect crimes. And who else but a group of mystery writers would eagerly look forward to a field trip to the local morgue?

I explained, in closing, that there’s sane method to our seeming madness: mystery authors are resolute researchers who care about the accuracy of the arcane facts about life and death we incorporate in our fiction.

Later, I found myself turning his question over again in my mind — from a broader perspective: What kind of person writes mystery novels? I thought back to the many different novelists I’ve met and wondered if there are there universal peculiarities that define mystery authors? Is it true, for example, that our senses of humor are more macabre than authors of historicals? Do we dress more conservatively than romance novelists? Or do we live in smaller (or bigger) cities than writers of literary fiction?

I quickly realized that using a specific personality trait to compare mystery writers with other novelists would lead me to the same answer: True for some mystery authors, not true for others. In any case, it’s probably impossible to propose a single umbrella quirk that will cover two widely dissimilar mystery writers — say Dorothy L. Sayers (Born and educated at Oxford University; Sleuth: Lord Peter Wimsey) and Mickey Spillane (Brooklyn-born, high-school graduate; Sleuth: P.I. Mike Hammer).

We are clearly a diverse group of scriveners.

However, I wasn’t ready to abandon my mind game. Instead, I shelved the idea of comparison and decided to focus on a few of the broad-brush attributes of the mystery writers I know. I won’t comment as to what extent they’re shared by writers in other genres. You can decide.

For starters, mystery writers have a festival of different day jobs. I say that confidently, because it’s a fine old tradition for mystery readers in different professions and occupations to try their hand at writing mysteries. Fans of Sherlock Holmes, Philip Marlowe, and Nero Wolfe know that Arthur Conan Doyle was a physician, that Raymond Chandler was a former oil company executive, and that Rex Stout was a banking innovator.

Mystery writers I’ve met include doctors, nurses, lawyers, nurses college professors, business executives, teachers of every kind and topic, computer gurus, journalists, advertising copywriters, military officers, priests, pastors, nuns, theologians, politicians, research scientists, social scientists, police officers, professional golfers… this list goes on and on.

The catalog would be even bigger if I included former day jobs. Many mystery writers are what I call “late-blooming novelists” — who publish their first mystery novel after age 50, and continue writing long after they retire.

Mystery writers often keep their day jobs because few of us can live on the royalties generated by our novels. Many — I’m tempted to say most — bring their nine-to-five expertise to their fiction — in the form of well-formed “Macguffins” — Alfred Hitchcock’s name for the items the characters care about in a storyline (think “Letters of Transit” in Casablanca).

Mystery writers are also determined mystery readers. There’s nothing unusual about readers of a particular genre becoming writers. Most novelists write the kind of fiction they like to read. But mystery writers remain stalwart mystery fans — although, most tend to be selective and have favorite subgenres and writers rather than read every variety of mystery fiction. Moreover, mystery writers are exuberant fans — free with praise for novels they enjoy written by “competing” writers. (Interestingly, I’ve never known a mystery writer who fretted much about “the competition.”)

Mystery writers are inveterate travelers — on the one hand for the love of travel, and on the other hand because we’re all looking for new settings for our mysteries.

Lastly, mystery writers are good writers — a fact contrary to some purveyors of “conventional wisdom” who hold that writing mystery fiction is “easy.” I make two points when I run into such a person: First, P.D. James was absolutely right when she famously said, “a first class mystery should also be a first class novel.” That’s not an easy thing to pull off. Second, a mystery writer must often explain complex topics in simple language — without boring the reader. That represents some of the most challenging writing one can do.

Actually … one more characteristic did pop into my head. Most of the mystery writers I know are chronic procrastinators. Instead of working on their latest novels (which is what I should be doing), they find good reasons to think about things like… what kind of people write mystery novels?

Leave a comment

The Fun of Mystery Fiction

What better way to launch a blog about mystery fiction than pointing out that unlike lots of other novels, the chief purpose of a mystery novel is… fun.

Many novelists write with the goal of changing readers’ minds and hearts. They want to edify, educate, enlighten, or encourage readers — or possibly advocate a cause. The lion’s share of mystery authors write chiefly to entertain readers, to provide several hours of enjoyment and escape. We rarely seek to change the world with our words; we’re satisfied with a smile and a nod from a reader who has relished a good read.

Now, when you ponder this cheerful raison d’être from a distance, it seems odd that so many readers actually enjoy mystery fiction. After all, why should supposedly “normal people” have fun contemplating murder, mayhem, and misfortune?

While there are a few “funny” mysteries out there (far fewer than all that try to be humorous), the encompassing answer seems to be that we like to vicariously experience the tribulations of other people who’ve been thrown into outrageously difficult circumstances.

Most mystery storylines begin by sending the protagonist’s world out of kilter. He, she, or they spend the rest of the story struggling to restore what’s been upset. Typically, the protagonist succeeds: good triumphs over evil… harmony replace chaos… traditional values replace anarchy… calm replaces fear. But whether a story has a neatly tied-up “happy” ending or not, we enjoy observing the struggle — especially the uncertainty (suspense) it engenders.

Mystery novels are enduring pleasures — and I mean that in two different senses.

On the one hand, the mystery novel has been an exceedingly popular fiction genre for more than a century. (In fact, expertly told stories of murder—in one form or another—have been popular fare for more than twenty-five hundred years.)

On the other hand, a well-crafted mystery novel never dies, which is why today’s mystery novelists must compete head to head with Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, Raymond Chandler, Rex Stout, and a pantheon of other long-dead novelists who still sell surprising numbers of books.

I say “surprising” in two senses, also.

First, the posthumous sales figures are impressive. (For example, Agatha Christie eBooks sell well on Kindle: Some of the Dame’s titles sell several hundred copies a month; they outsell a flood of new mysteries published this year.)

Second, there are contemporary readers who wonder why so many people intentionally buy “dull” books to read. By today’s standards, the classics are oddly written. What present-day writer would spend the opening 75 pages of a novel introducing a dozen eccentric characters and describing an English manor house in sumptuous detail?

I’ve stopped explaining to the skeptics that there can be joy in “dullness.” They just don’t “get” that I’m often in the mood for quiet meandering around interesting settings, gentle story pacing, slow observations of fascinating characters, and a torrent of details about bellringing, painting, fishing, or cooking—all the while in the capable hands of a skilled writer who never uses five words when ten will do. It’s a charming way to relax, to escape a frenetic world—for those of us who do, on occasion, like that sort of thing.

Of course, if fast-paced storytelling is your métier, there are countless recently written mysteries that will satisfy. One of the delightful aspects of the mystery genre is that it accommodates so many different styles and voices. I think this is one of the reasons why so many people try their hand at writing mysteries.

As we note in the header, this blog is for readers and writers of mystery fiction. Before I began writing mystery novels, I read them. At least one a week. I still read dozens a year — and watch many mysteries on TV.

As a group, mystery novelists are avid, knowledgeable fans of their genre. More so, I think, than authors in other popular genres. And, many of the mystery readers I know have the notion tucked away in their minds that someday they will write a mystery novel.

So … welcome to The Benrey Blog. Janet and I hope you will visit regularly.

1 Comment

A Place to Talk About Mystery Fiction…

Janet and I love to write mystery fiction. We also love to talk about it with readers and other novelists. We — and our guest bloggers — will cover many topics, from reflections on classic mystery novels, to news about the latest cozies, mysteries, and police procedurals, to proven writing techniques, and to the impact of the “new publishing paradigm” on mystery fiction.

We want your comments. Please jump in!

And PLEASE subscribe, so that you won’t miss any posts. We’ve FIXED the “Subscribe” Widget to the right. It now works fine!